My Horrible Idea
(Using Horror Movies to Teach English)
  • How to Use Monsters in the Classroom
    • What Can Monsters Teach Us?
    • Rhetorical Problems of Purpose, Audience, and Genre
    • Doubt: A Parable
  • Literary Stuff
  • Guest Blogs
    • SCARY MARY: A STUDY OF TONE
    • Horror Movie Survey
    • First Dates and Wisecracking Werewolfs
    • Rachel Tucker: A Master Gardener's take on The Purge
    • Janice Cheng: Horror & Logic
    • Zach Butler: Why All the Horror?
  • Movie Lists
    • MEAT IS MURDER: MY TOP FIVE LIST OF CANNIBAL MOVIES
    • CHRISTMAS HORROR MOVIES
    • TRIBUTE TO MR. VINCENT LEONARD PRICE, JR.
  • Archives
    • MONSTER MOVIES >
      • DRACULA (1931)
      • THE MUMMY (1932)
      • KING KONG (1933)
      • THE WOLF MAN (1941)
      • CREATURE FROM THE BLACK LAGOON (1954)
      • THEM! (1959)
      • THE HOUND OF THE BASKERVILLES (1959)
      • THE WASP WOMAN (1959)
      • THE DEADLY BEES (1966)
      • PLANET OF THE APES (1968)
      • EMPIRE OF THE ANTS (1977)
      • THE SWARM (1978)
      • THE BEES (1978)
      • ALIEN (1979)
      • THE ATTIC (1980)
      • CUJO (1981)
      • PREDATOR (1987)
      • DEAD ALIVE (1992)
      • CONGO (1995)
      • JAWS (1975)
      • DEVIL DOG: THE HOUND OF HELL (1978)
      • LEGION OF FIRE: KILLER ANTS (1998)
      • DEEP BLUE SEA (1999)
      • OPEN WATER (2003)
      • THE HIVE A LOOK AT LITERARY ENTOMOLOGY (2008)
      • THE REEF (2010)
      • THE GREY (2011)
      • SHARKNADO (2013)
      • WER (2013)
      • THE BABADOOK (2014)
    • HONORED DIRECTORS >
      • SHIVERS (1975)
      • VIDEDROME (1983)
      • THE FLY (1986)
      • DEAD RINGERS (1988)
      • CHRISTINE (1983)
      • THE THING (1982)
      • PRINCE OF DARKNESS (1987)
      • THEY LIVE (1988)
      • IN THE MOUTH OF MADNESS (1994)
      • REPULSION (1965)
      • THE TENANT (1976)
      • THE FEARLESS VAMPIRE KILLERS (1967)
      • ROSEMARY'S BABY (1968)
      • FRANKENSTEIN (1910)
      • THE OLD DARK HOUSE (1932)
      • THE INVISIBLE MAN (1933)
      • BRIDE OF FRANKENSTEIN (1935)
      • SALEM'S LOT (1979)
      • THE FUNHOUSE (1981)
      • LIFE FORCE (1985)
      • POLTERGEIST (1982)
      • THE TEXAS CHAIN SAW MASSACRE (1974)
      • THE LAST HOUSE ON THE LEFT (1972)
      • THE HILLS HAVE EYES (1977)
      • A NIGHTMARE ON ELM STREET (1984)
      • SCREAM (1996)
    • KOREAN FLICKS >
      • 조용한 가족 (aka The Quiet Family 1998)
      • 소름 (aka SORUM 2001)
      • 세이 예스 (aka SAY YES 2001)
      • 폰 (aka Phone 2002)
      • 령 aka DEAD FRIEND aka THE GHOST (2004)
      • 거미슾 (aka SPIDER FOREST 2004)
      • 분홍신 aka THE RED SHOES (2005)
      • 레드 아이 (AKA RED EYE 2005)
      • 스승의은혜 (AKA TO SIR, WITH LOVE 2006)
      • 신데렐라 (aka Cinderella 2006)
      • 아파트 (aka APT 2006)
      • 두사람이다 aka VOICES (2007)
      • Alone (2007)
      • 므이 (aka MOUI 2007)
      • 헨젤 과 그레텔 (aka Hansel & Gretel 2007)
      • 추격자 (aka The Chaser 2008)
      • 외톨이 (맘 LONER 2008)
      • 고死: 피의 중간고사 (aka DEATH BELL 2008)
      • 불신지옥 (aka POSSESSED 2009)
      • 요가학완 aka YOGA CLASS (2009)
      • 베스트 세러 (aka BEST SELLER 2010)
      • 악마를 보았다 (aka I SAW THE DEVIL 2010)
      • 고양이: 죽음을보는 두개의눈 (aka THE CAT 2011)
      • 기생령 (aka GHASTLY 2011)
      • 무서운이야기 (AKA HORROR STORIES 2012)
      • 더웹툰 예고살린 (AKA KILLER TOON 2013)
      • 뫼비우스 (aka MOEBIUS 2013)
    • THRILLERS >
      • DEAD OF NIGHT (1945)
      • STRANGERS ON A TRAIN (1951)
      • REAR WINDOW (1954)
      • THE TROUBLE WITH HARRY (1955)
      • NORTH BY NORTHWEST (1959)
      • THE BIRDS (1963)
      • STRIP NUDE FOR YOUR KILLER (1975)
      • BODY HEAT (1981)
      • CAT PEOPLE (1982)
      • JAGGED EDGE (1985)
      • BEDROOM WINDOW (1987)
      • NINE QUEENS (2000)
      • WHAT LIES BENEATH (2000)
      • THE DESCENT (2005)
      • THE EXPERIMENT (2010)
      • YOU'RE NEXT (2011)
      • 의뢰인 (aka The Client 2011)
      • ABRAHAM LINCOLN VAMPIRE HUNTER (2012)
      • TOAD ROAD (2012)
      • FEAR LIVES HERE (2013)
      • 런닝 맨 (AKA RUNNING MAN 2013)
      • GRAND PIANO (2013)
      • HOURS (2013)
      • BLUE RUIN (2013)
      • HOUSE OF GOOD AND EVIL (2013)
      • THE PURGE (2013)
      • 더테러라이브 (aka The Terror Live 2013)
      • THE HUMAN RACE (2013)
      • DAYLIGHT (2013)
      • HOUSEBOUND (2014)
      • THE GUEST (2014)
    • PSYCHOS >
      • DR. JEKYLL AND MR. HYDE (1931)
      • ROPE (1948)
      • 1950's AWESOMENESS >
        • ROCKETSHIP X-M (1950)
        • THE MAN WHO CHEATED HIMSELF (1950)
        • WHAT THE BUTLER SAW (1950)
        • THE FLYING SAUCER (1950)
        • ROBOT MONSTER (1953)
        • PHANTOM FROM SPACE (1953)
        • TARGET EARTH (1954)
        • THE SNOW CREATURE (1954)
        • KILLERS FROM SPACE (1954)
        • IT CONQUERED THE WORLD (1956)
        • THE MOLE PEOPLE (1956)
        • THE GAMMA PEOPLE (1956)
        • THE LAND UNKNOWN (1957)
        • THE BRAIN FROM PLANET AROUS (1957)
        • I WAS A TEENAGE FRANKENSTEIN (1957)
        • THE NIGHT THE WORLD EXPLODED (1957)
        • THE AMAZING COLOSSAL MAN (1957)
        • THE GIANT CLAW (1957)
        • KRONOS (1957)
        • LA CRAVATE (1957)
        • THE THREE FACES OF EVE (1957)
        • THE MONOLITH MONSTERS (1957)
        • I BURY THE LIVING (1958)
        • THE MONSTER OF PIEDRAS BLANCAS (1959)
        • TEENAGERS FROM OUTER SPACE (1959)
        • ATTACK OF THE GIANT LEECHES (1959)
        • BEAST FROM HAUNTED CAVE (1959)
        • I EAT YOUR SKIN (1964)
      • LES DIABOLIQUES (1955)
      • PSYCHO (1960)
      • WHATEVER HAPPENED TO BABY JANE (1962)
      • TAXI DRIVER (1976)
      • ¿Quien Puede Matar a un Niño? (aka WHO CAN KILL A CHILD? aka THE ISLAND OF THE DAMNED 1976)
      • THE SHINING (1980)
      • FRIDAY THE 13TH (1980)
      • MISERY (1990)
      • CAPE FEAR (1991)
      • THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS (1991)
      • SWOON (1992)
      • DEATH AND THE MAIDEN (1992)
      • RESERVOIR DOGS (1992)
      • SCHINDLER'S LIST (1993)
      • NATURAL BORN KILLERS (1994)
      • THE CELL (2000)
      • SEXY BEAST (2000)
      • ONE HOUR PHOTO (2002)
      • MONSTER (2003)
      • WRONG TURN (2003)
      • WOLF CREEK (2005)
      • SIN CITY (2005)
      • HARD CANDY (2005)
      • THE LAST KING OF SCOTLAND (2006)
      • MR. BROOKS (2007)
      • THE DARK KNIGHT (2008)
      • SKYFALL (2012)
    • THE SUPERNATURAL >
      • NOSFERATU (1922)
      • CARNIVAL OF SOULS (1962)
      • LET'S SCARE JESSICA TO DEATH (1971)
      • THE CHANGELING (1980)
      • THE EVIL DEAD (1981)
      • ANGEL HEART (1987)
      • HELLRAISER (1987)
      • CHILD'S PLAY (1988)
      • THE SIXTH SENSE (1999)
      • AUDITION (1999)
      • END OF DAYS (1999)
      • STIGMATA (1999)
      • Richard Matheson Tribute: A STIR OF Memories
      • THE GIFT (2000)
      • THE RING (2002)
      • THE GRUDGE (2004)
      • THE EXORCISM OF EMILY ROSE (2005)
      • THE AMITYVILLE HORROR (2005)
      • DARK WATER (2005)
      • SILENT HILL (2006)
      • PARANORMAL ACTIVITY (2007)
      • LAKE MUNGO (2008)
      • DRAG ME TO HELL (2009)
      • INSIDIOUS (2010)
      • WE ARE WHAT WE ARE (2013)
      • MAMA (2013)
      • CARRIE (2013)
      • OCULUS (2013)
      • THE CONJURING (2013)
      • LATE PHASES (2014)
      • THE TAKING OF DEBORAH LOGAN (2014)
      • JESSABELLE (2014)
      • ANNABELLE (2014)
  • Psycho Hall of Fame
  • Crimson Peak
  • An America Terror
  • The Beat Goes On: Horror Franchises

Mr. Brooks (2007)

8/9/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Today’s psycho comes to us in a wonderful sleeper film titled simply Mr. Brooks. Earl Brooks (played by Kevin Costner) is the man of the year; he’s a great husband, and he’s a loving father. He also just happens to be addicted to killing people. This film touches on the addiction concept briefly, but doesn’t linger because there’s far too much other juicy stuff to explore. He is not alone on his exploration…he has an imaginary friend (so to speak) in Marshall (played by the delightful William Hurt). Throw into the mix another character named Mr. Smith (played by Dane Cook) who is blackmailing Mr. Brooks to take him along on his killing sprees and teach him how to do it and you’ve got an excellent triumvirate of evil, and a great reason for talking about Freud’s division of the human mind.

Picture
PictureDane Cook as Mr. Smith
According to Sigmund Freud, the mind was divided into three parts: the Id, the Ego, and the Superego. In this narrative we see a literal realization of those parts interacting. The Id is all impulse and desire, and it wants those desires gratified immediately. It has no moral sense. All it wants is pleasure. It pressures the conscious mind into giving it what it wants and then releasing that pressure when it gets what it wants. In this narrative, that is Mr. Smith. Smith blackmails Mr. Brooks to get what he wants. That’s a kind of pressure he deploys to gratify what he wants. He has photos he took of Mr. Brooks implicating him as the Thumbprint Killer. He threatens Mr. Brooks with exposure if his desires are not gratified. Mr. Smith is all ID in this film. We see him pout when he doesn’t get his way…another kind of pressure. We see him throwing tantrums when Mr. Brooks denies him immediate gratification by putting off the act of murder. The ID is driven by sexuality and aggression. We see both of these in Mr. Smith as he is quite a voyeur and documents the sex acts of his neighbors regularly. There’s no moral dilemma he struggles with when it comes to what he is asking for. There’s no thought of consequences at all. It’s just pure desire.


PictureKevin Costner as Mr. Brooks.
Mr. Brooks is always in control. It’s part of what has made him a success in his business and probably what led to him being named man of the year. He is methodical in approach to killing. It’s never about passion or emotion. It’s all about the thrill which has led to it becoming an addiction. He is meticulous in his execution of his executions. Every detail is planned. When the cop chasing after him is explaining his M.O. to another cop, she points to a vacuum cleaner and says, “I bet you there’s not a vacuum cleaner bag in there. He always vacuums the house after his crimes.” She opens it up and proves herself correct. The other cop says, “What if he killed someone who didn’t have a vacuum cleaner?” to which she replies, “He wouldn’t do that.” Once again proving his crimes are methodical and not passion based. It’s Mr. Brooks’ experience that is used to control Mr. Smith. He never loses patience with Mr. Smith. He teaches him what he knows in a very creepy mentoring kind of way. But he is in control of the Id making him the Ego.


PictureMarshall is one demented Jiminy Cricket.
Now we come to the most complex character…Marshall. First, I love that his name is Marshall, which means ‘to guide’. That cracks me up because Marshall is almost a cheerleader for Mr. Brooks’ killing sprees. The job of the Superego is the keeper of the Moral Consciousness. It’s supposed to be the guardian of our sense of right and wrong. Marshall is one messed up Superego in that sense. He councils Mr. Brooks in fulfilling his addiction of killing, but also is a voice of reason. He’s very intellectual and extremely articulate in matters of right and wrong. They just don’t match up to what civilized sociality would deem right and wrong. The Superego is a collection of these morals accumulated from Parents, Communities, Religion, Society. Marshall seems to have developed his own moral code and it’s that code by which he councils Mr. Brooks. 


PictureWilliam Hurt and Kevin Costner...they are amazing to watch together.
In that sense of battling for control between Mr. Smith’s desires and Marshall’s messed up moral code, it becomes Mr. Brooks’ job to mediate between the two. And THAT is the narrative we see unfold. It’s never a moral struggle, for Marshall and Mr. Brooks or Mr. Smith, of whether killing is right or wrong. Mr. Brooks knows it’s wrong. Marshall knows it’s wrong. But they both know it has become an addiction. Mr. Brooks has managed to stop for two years by going to AA meetings. We have seen time and time again the destructive nature of addiction to ruin a life. Here it’s not drugs or alcohol, but the thrill of killing that has taken over Mr. Brooks. The ironic twist is that he discovers that whatever this “thing” is in him, his daughter has inherited making for an even more twisted narrative.


I can’t give any more away without spoiling the movie, so I’ll stop there. As a visual depiction of the Freud’s tripartite mind, this film is an excellent example of that struggle. Give it a watch and tell me what you think!

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    ID, EGO, SUPEREGO

    Freud's division of the mind.

    Archives

    August 2014

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.